Things feel a lot different at Penn State.
For years, the conversation around the Nittany Lions was simple.
When is James Franklin going to win the big one?
That question is gone now.
Not because Penn State won the big one.
Because Franklin is gone.
Matt Campbell is now the head coach. Rocco Becht is now the quarterback. A huge chunk of the Iowa State roster followed Campbell to State College. This is not just a normal coaching change.
This feels like a program reset.
Penn State went 7-6 last season and 3-6 in the Big Ten, and the year never came close to matching the preseason expectations. The Nittany Lions started with playoff hopes, but injuries, inconsistency and a shocking loss to UCLA changed everything.
Now the program looks completely different.
New coach.
New quarterback.
New offensive identity.
New defensive pieces.
Same expectations.
That is the hard part.
HEAD COACH
- Matt Campbell, entering year one at Penn State
- Penn State went 7-6 last season.
- The Nittany Lions finished 3-6 in the Big Ten.
- Campbell went 72-55 at Iowa State.
- Penn State has only a few true returning starters from last year’s team.
This is one of the most fascinating hires in the Big Ten.
Campbell did a strong job at Iowa State. That is a hard place to win, and he turned the Cyclones into a program that could be competitive in the Big 12. He developed players. He built toughness. He won enough to become a major name for bigger jobs.
Now he gets one.
Penn State is not Iowa State.
That cuts both ways.
The resources are bigger. The recruiting ceiling is bigger. The fan base is bigger. The brand is bigger.
But the expectations are bigger too.
At Iowa State, being competitive mattered. At Penn State, being competitive is not enough. This program expects to win big. It expects to compete for the playoff. It expects to matter nationally.
That is why this year is so interesting.
Campbell did not come alone. He brought a lot of familiar players with him, especially on offense. That gives Penn State more continuity than most first-year coaching staffs would have.
But it also raises the question.
Is this Penn State with Iowa State pieces?
Or is this Iowa State wearing Penn State uniforms?
That may sound harsh, but it is the real question.
The Big Ten schedule is different. The weekly physicality is different. The expectations are different. Campbell has to prove that the system can scale up in a tougher environment.
QUARTERBACK
The quarterback is Rocco Becht.
That gives Penn State a very clear identity right away.
Becht is not some untested transfer. He has played a ton of college football. He has thrown more than 1,000 career passes and has 64 touchdowns with 27 interceptions in his college career.
That experience matters.
He is not going to walk into a Big Ten road game and look overwhelmed by the moment. He has been in close games. He has run Campbell’s offense. He knows what the staff wants.
That is the good part.
The numbers also show why there are questions.
Becht completed about 60.7% of his career passes at Iowa State. Last year, he ranked only 58th nationally in total pass attempts and 92nd in completion percentage. That is not elite efficiency.
The pressure numbers are the bigger concern.
He was under pressure on about 40% of his throws last season, and in those situations, he threw zero touchdowns and four interceptions. He also completed only 36% of his deep balls, going 16-of-44 with six touchdowns and two picks.
That is the line between solid and special.
Penn State does not need Becht to become the best quarterback in the country. But it does need him to be better than simply functional. If the Nittany Lions want to push toward the top of the Big Ten, Becht has to create enough explosives and avoid the mistakes that can kill drives.
He can keep Penn State in games.
The question is whether he can win the games Penn State has been trying to win for years.
That is a very different standard.
THE REST OF THE OFFENSE
The offense has a lot of Iowa State flavor.
That is not necessarily a bad thing.
Start at running back.
Quinton Martin Jr. gives Penn State one returning option after rushing for 103 yards as a freshman in the Pinstripe Bowl against Clemson. He is one of the few Penn State offensive pieces who was already in the program and still figures to matter.
Then comes the Iowa State connection.
Carson Hansen comes over after rushing for more than 1,700 yards and 19 touchdowns with the Cyclones. He should be a major part of the offense right away.
James Peoples also comes in from Ohio State, giving the backfield another talented option.
That should be a good room.
It has to be.
Campbell’s teams have generally wanted to run the ball, and Penn State ran it on 57% of its plays last season. The Nittany Lions threw only about 25.7 passes per game, so this offense is probably still going to lean on the ground game and the tight ends.
Speaking of tight ends, that might be the most interesting part of the roster.
Benjamin Brahmer and Gabe Burkle both followed Campbell from Iowa State. Those two were major pieces of the Cyclones’ passing game, and they give Becht immediate familiarity. That matters a lot.
A quarterback changing schools with his tight ends is not normal.
Penn State also brings in Chase Sowell and has Brett Eskildsen in the receiver mix. Again, there is a lot of Iowa State carryover here.
The offensive line has to come together.
Anthony Donkoh is the one returning starter up front, and that is a good piece to have. Malachi Goodman and Trevor Buhr are also expected to factor in after coming in as transfers.
The concern is whether this group can be physical enough quickly.
Penn State scored 29 points per game last season, but the offense averaged only 353 yards per game. That is not good enough if the goal is to compete at the top of the Big Ten.
The Iowa State offense last season averaged fewer points than Penn State, but more yards.
So the question is simple.
Can Campbell’s offense become more explosive with Penn State talent?
If the answer is yes, this team becomes very interesting.
If the answer is no, Penn State may still feel stuck in the same place — just with different people.
DEFENSE
This side of the ball is basically being rebuilt too.
Penn State does have a couple of important returning pieces in the secondary.
Audavion Collins is back. So is Zion Tracy.
Those two give the Nittany Lions at least some continuity on the back end, and that matters when so much else is changing.
But the defense also has a heavy Iowa State influence.
The top four tacklers from Iowa State transferred to Penn State. That is wild. It also tells you how much Campbell believed in bringing the core of his program with him.
Kooper Ebel comes in at linebacker. Caleb Bacon is also part of the defensive front-seven picture. Tony Rojas gives Penn State a familiar linebacker name from last year’s roster, and he should be one of the key pieces in the middle of the defense.
In the secondary, Marcus Neal Jr. comes over after earning All-Big 12 recognition at Iowa State.
That is not just depth.
That is real production.
Penn State also added multiple defensive tackles through the portal, clearly trying to get bigger and stronger up front. That has to work because the Big Ten will test you there every week.
The comparison point is interesting.
Iowa State allowed 21.4 points per game and 370 yards per game last season. That is solid. Penn State’s defense was better in yardage allowed last year, giving up 326 yards per game, but this is not the same roster anymore.
So the question is not really what Penn State did last year.
The question is whether Campbell’s defensive core can translate.
Can Iowa State’s best tacklers become Big Ten answers?
Can Penn State’s returning defensive backs help hold everything together?
Can the transfer defensive tackles make the front sturdy enough?
There is enough talent here to be good.
But there is enough new here to be nervous.
SCHEDULE
The schedule is the biggest reason to believe Penn State can start fast.
The Nittany Lions open with Marshall at home, then go to Temple on Sept. 12. After that, they host Buffalo and Wisconsin.
That means three of the first four games are at home.
The Temple game is interesting because it is on the road, and I always like when a Power Four program is willing to go play a Group of Five team away from home. Temple has gotten some big programs to do that, and Penn State is one of them.
After Wisconsin, Penn State goes to Northwestern on Oct. 2.
So the first five games are Marshall, Temple, Buffalo, Wisconsin and Northwestern.
Penn State fans are going to expect 5-0.
They should.
That does not mean it will be automatic, but if this team wants to be taken seriously in the Big Ten, that is the start it needs.
Then comes the real test.
USC comes to Beaver Stadium on Oct. 10.
That is a massive game. It is a long trip for the Trojans, and it should be one of the first real measuring-stick moments for Campbell’s new team.
One week later, Penn State goes to Michigan.
That back-to-back stretch will tell us a lot.
After a bye, the Nittany Lions host Purdue on Halloween, go to Washington, then host Minnesota and Rutgers before finishing at Maryland.
The schedule is favorable in one major way.
Penn State does not play Ohio State, Oregon or Indiana.
That is a huge deal.
In this version of the Big Ten, avoiding those three teams matters. The Nittany Lions still have USC, Michigan and Washington, but they miss the top of the league.
That gives Penn State a real chance to outperform expectations if the new roster comes together quickly.
OUTLOOK
I understand why people are split on Penn State.
On one hand, this is a major reset.
New coach. New quarterback. New offense. New defensive core. New identity. A roster that looks like a Penn State-Iowa State hybrid.
That is a lot to process.
On the other hand, this is not a normal reset with no continuity.
Campbell brought his quarterback. He brought his tight ends. He brought key defenders. He brought players who already know what he wants. That can speed things up.
The best-case scenario is that Rocco Becht gives Penn State steady quarterback play, Carson Hansen and Quinton Martin Jr. power a strong run game, Benjamin Brahmer and Gabe Burkle become safety blankets in the passing game, and the Iowa State defensive transfers immediately raise the floor.
If that happens, Penn State can be a top-25 team and maybe more.
The worst-case scenario is that the offense looks too much like Iowa State’s offense, Becht is only average against Big Ten pressure, the line takes time to settle, and the defense is not as strong as it was under the old version of Penn State.
That is possible too.
If Campbell can pair his system with Penn State’s resources, this can work.
Maybe quickly.
But the USC-Michigan stretch is where we find out.
Start 5-0, split those two, and Penn State becomes one of the more interesting stories in the Big Ten.
Lose early, look clunky, and people will start wondering whether this is a rebuild that needs more time.
Either way, Penn State is different now.
And different might be exactly what this program needed.
Full disclosure: I use AI tools to format my research into an article encompassing all of the information.