East Carolina had one of the quieter good seasons in college football last year.
That sounds strange to say about a team that went 9-4 and 6-2 in the American, but it is true.
The league had so many headline teams that ECU almost got pushed into the background. Tulane made the playoff. Navy was one of the best stories in the country. South Florida won at Florida and looked dangerous. Memphis was in the race for a while. North Texas played for the league title.
And there were the Pirates, just winning games.
Now the question is whether they can do it again.
ECU is coming off a nine-win season, but this roster looks different. Katin Houser is gone to Illinois. The offense lost major pieces. The defense has only a few returning starters. The Pirates are trying to chase their first back-to-back nine-win seasons in school history while replacing a lot of what made last year work.
That makes this one of the more interesting teams in the American.
HEAD COACH
- Blake Harrell, entering his second full season as East Carolina’s head coach
- The Pirates finished 6-2 in the American last season.
- Harrell is 14-5 at ECU.
- East Carolina has won seven or more games in four of the last five seasons.
Harrell has done a really good job.
East Carolina was not treated like one of the biggest stories in the American last season, but the Pirates won nine games and were a legitimate factor in the league.
Now comes the harder part.
Can ECU sustain it?
The Pirates averaged 30.8 points per game last season, which ranked near the top 25 nationally. They averaged more than 440 yards per game, which was even better. They also ran the ball a ton, ranking near the top 10 nationally in rush attempts per game.
That was the identity.
Move the ball. Run it. Stay efficient. Put pressure on defenses.
But a lot of that offense is gone.
So this season is not just about whether ECU can be good again.
It is about whether Harrell has built something that can survive turnover.
QUARTERBACK
This is the biggest question on the roster.
Katin Houser is gone, and that is a big deal. He gave East Carolina stability at quarterback and helped the Pirates become one of the better offenses in the American.
Now the job appears to come down to Emory Williams and Mitch Griffis.
Williams comes from Miami, where he played sparingly. He completed about 63% of his passes with 813 yards, four touchdowns and two interceptions.
That is not a huge sample.
But it is something.
Griffis brings more experience. He previously played at Wake Forest and Texas Tech, and his career numbers are more complete. He has thrown for more than 2,300 yards with 17 touchdowns and eight interceptions, completing about 61% of his passes.
That experience matters.
ECU is not starting over with a quarterback who has never been in a college game. Both options have been in Power Four programs. Both were recruited at a high level. Both have seen what major college football looks like.
That does not guarantee anything.
But it gives ECU options.
Williams may have more untapped upside. Griffis may give them the steadier floor. Either way, East Carolina needs one of them to win the job and settle the offense quickly.
This cannot become a season-long quarterback drama.
The Pirates have too many new pieces for that.
THE REST OF THE OFFENSE
The offense begins with Brock Spalding.
He is the only returning starter on that side of the ball, and he has to become even more important this season.
Spalding had 42 catches for 554 yards and three touchdowns last year. Before that, he had only nine catches over the previous three seasons.
So last year was his breakout.
Now ECU needs him to prove it was not a one-year flash.
That is a big ask, but it is also a big opportunity. Spalding should be the first read for whoever wins the quarterback job. He gives the Pirates at least one proven target, and that is important with so much change around him.
The rest of the receiver room has been rebuilt.
Ray Ray Joseph Jr. comes in from Miami. Jeremiah Melvin comes in from Wake Forest. Landon Sides comes in from North Texas. Those are three interesting additions, and they give ECU a chance to build a completely new rotation around Spalding.
The running back room is also new.
Ashton Gray comes in from North Texas, and Michael Allen comes in from Marshall. Gray is especially intriguing because of how he finished last season. He had 16 carries for 152 yards and two touchdowns against San Diego State in the New Mexico Bowl, and that was not against a bad defense.
That kind of finish gets people’s attention.
Allen has moved around, but he has real experience too. ECU does not need one of these backs to become a superstar right away. It just needs the run game to stay dangerous enough to keep the offense balanced.
The offensive line is another reset.
The Pirates lost some high-end talent up front, including all-conference and All-American-level players. Brandon Best and Hayes Creel are two of the names expected to help rebuild the line.
That may be the key to everything.
Last year, ECU could run the ball and control games. If the offensive line takes a step back, the new quarterback has a much harder job. If the line comes together quickly, the Pirates have enough skill talent to still be dangerous.
DEFENSE
The defense has a few known pieces, but not a lot.
Jasiyah Robinson is back on the defensive line, and DJ Johnson Jr. is back at linebacker. Those are the two returning starters to build around.
Johnson is especially important because he brings production and experience in the middle of the defense. Robinson gives ECU a starting point up front.
But the Pirates lost a lot.
That means the transfer additions have to matter quickly.
Kevon Merrell Jr. is back in the secondary after coming up with an interception in the Military Bowl, and ECU added several defensive backs to reshape the back end. Zyeir Gamble comes in from App State, and there are other new pieces who could factor into the rotation.
At linebacker, Cade Law and Crews Law come over from Memphis after starting their careers at North Carolina. That gives ECU more Power Four-connected talent in the middle of the defense.
This unit was good enough last year.
Opponents averaged 21.5 points per game and 367 yards per game. That is a solid defensive profile, especially in a league with several good offenses.
But the question is whether it can stay there with so many new faces.
The Pirates do not need the defense to be elite.
They need it to avoid falling off.
If ECU’s defense stays solid while the offense figures itself out, the Pirates can stay in the top half of the American. If the defense slips early, the schedule could become a problem.
SCHEDULE
The schedule starts with a monster.
East Carolina opens at Alabama.
That is a brutal way to begin a season with a new quarterback and a rebuilt roster. The Pirates do not need to be judged solely by that game, but they do need to come out of it healthy and organized.
After Alabama, ECU hosts App State, then goes to Old Dominion. Two of the first three games are on the road, and both road games are tricky for very different reasons.
Then the Pirates host North Carolina Central before getting into American play.
The league schedule begins with Rice on Oct. 10. Then ECU goes to UAB on Oct. 15 and Memphis on Oct. 22, giving the Pirates back-to-back Thursday road games. That is not easy.
After that, ECU hosts Temple on Halloween, then hosts South Florida on Nov. 6.
That South Florida game could be a big one in the American race.
The closing stretch includes back-to-back road games at Charlotte and Army, then the regular-season finale against Florida Atlantic.
There are a few schedule concerns.
Two of the first three are on the road. Four of the first seven are away from home. The Pirates have multiple non-Saturday games. And the November road swing to Charlotte and Army is not ideal.
The schedule is not impossible.
But for a team replacing this much, it is not exactly friendly either.
OUTLOOK
I like East Carolina.
I just do not think this is an easy season to project.
The Pirates were really good last year. Nine wins. Six league wins. A good offense. A solid defense. A team that probably deserved more attention than it got.
But now they have to replace the quarterback, rebuild the running game, reshape the offensive line, find more receivers around Spalding, and replace a lot on defense.
That is a lot.
The best-case scenario is that Emory Williams or Mitch Griffis wins the quarterback job quickly, Brock Spalding becomes a true No. 1 receiver, Ashton Gray gives the offense a real lead back, and the rebuilt offensive line comes together faster than expected.
If that happens, ECU can stay in the American race.
The worst-case scenario is that the quarterback battle drags, the offensive line takes too long to settle, the run game loses its edge, and the defense cannot replace enough production to keep games manageable.
That is possible too.
Last year’s team was better than people realized.
This year’s team has more questions than people may realize.
That does not mean ECU is going away.
It just means the Pirates have to prove they can reload, not rebuild.
Full disclosure: I use AI tools to format my research into an article encompassing all of the information.










